Skip to content
20% OFF WITH CODE "PILLOWPARTY" WHEN YOU SPEND $40+
20% OFF WITH CODE "PILLOWPARTY" WHEN YOU SPEND $40+

Beginner Anal Toys

Small Plugs, Trainer Sets & Everything You Need to Start Slow

The golden rule of anal play? Patience. The silver rule? More lube. There is no bronze rule; go back to the first two.

Curious about anal play but not sure where to start? You're in very good company. Anal pleasure is for every body: the area is packed with nerve endings, and for people with a prostate it's also the route to one of the body's most sensitive spots. The key is going slowly, using plenty of lube, and choosing a toy built for safety. Every toy in this collection is designed for anal play, starts on the small side, and is made from easy-to-clean materials like silicone or stainless steel.

Small Butt Plugs - The Gentlest Start

A small plug is the classic first anal toy. It's short, narrow and designed to sit comfortably once inserted, so you can get used to the feeling of fullness without any thrusting. Wear it for a few minutes during solo play or sex, then remove it slowly. Shorter sessions are the right way to begin.

Anal Trainer Sets - Grow at Your Own Pace

Trainer sets include two or three plugs in graduated sizes. Start with the smallest and only move up when it feels completely comfortable, over days or weeks rather than in one session. A set is often better value than buying plugs one by one, and it takes the guesswork out of choosing a size.

Anal Lube - Not Optional

Unlike the vagina, the anus doesn't produce its own lubrication, so lube is essential, every time. Choose a thicker water-based gel made for anal play. It stays put longer and is safe with every silicone toy here. Reapply often; if anything starts to drag, you need more.

  • The 9's, The Silver Starter, Bejeweled Stainless Steel Plug Pink | Butt Plug

    Original price $14.95 - Original price $14.95
    Original price
    $14.95
    $14.95 - $14.95
    Current price $14.95

    DESCRIPTION Stainless steel butt plug for first timers features a colorful jewel on its base. MATERIAL Stainless Steel NOTE Comes with drawstring c...

    View full details
    Original price $14.95 - Original price $14.95
    Original price
    $14.95
    $14.95 - $14.95
    Current price $14.95
  • VeDO Quaker Anal Vibe - Midnight Madness - Men's

    Original price $33.09 - Original price $33.09
    Original price
    $33.09
    $33.09 - $33.09
    Current price $33.09

    DESCRIPTION The gently curved tip and graduated beads of this vibe are ideal for easing your way into anal play. The long bulbous shaft and silky s...

    View full details
    Original price $33.09 - Original price $33.09
    Original price
    $33.09
    $33.09 - $33.09
    Current price $33.09
  • Playboy Tail Trainer 3-Piece Silicone Anal Training Kit Navy | Anal Kit

    Original price $51.99 - Original price $51.99
    Original price
    $51.99
    $51.99 - $51.99
    Current price $51.99

    DESCRIPTION Freedom to Play:Size up safely with Tail Teaser our Anal Training Kit. These velvet-smooth silicone butt plugs come in 3 sizes – small,...

    View full details
    Original price $51.99 - Original price $51.99
    Original price
    $51.99
    $51.99 - $51.99
    Current price $51.99
  • Lovense Hush 2 Bluetooth Remote-Controlled Vibrating Butt Plug XS 1 in.

    Original price $106.92 - Original price $106.92
    Original price
    $106.92
    $106.92 - $106.92
    Current price $106.92

    DESCRIPTION Super-Powerful and Wearable Butt Plug. The new sleek and smooth design makes it more comfortable for short or long sessions. We've upda...

    View full details
    Original price $106.92 - Original price $106.92
    Original price
    $106.92
    $106.92 - $106.92
    Current price $106.92
  • Pjur Back Door Comfort Anal Glide 100ml Water Based Lubricant

    Original price $20.24 - Original price $20.24
    Original price
    $20.24
    $20.24 - $20.24
    Current price $20.24

    The long-lasting lubricating properties of the silicone formula and the addition of natural jojoba extracts help relax the anal sphincter while mak...

    View full details
    Original price $20.24 - Original price $20.24
    Original price
    $20.24
    $20.24 - $20.24
    Current price $20.24
  • JO H2O Anal - Original - Lubricant (Water-Based) 4 oz. / 120 ml

    Original price $15.42 - Original price $15.42
    Original price
    $15.42
    $15.42 - $15.42
    Current price $15.42

    DESCRIPTION JO® H2O ANAL. This product provides a comfortable glide with quality ingredients. The silky-smooth buttery body. JO® H2O ANAL is easy t...

    View full details
    Original price $15.42 - Original price $15.42
    Original price
    $15.42
    $15.42 - $15.42
    Current price $15.42
  • Sliquid Sassy Intimate Gel Booty Formula 4.2 oz.

    Original price $13.20 - Original price $13.20
    Original price
    $13.20
    $13.20 - $13.20
    Current price $13.20

    Sassy Intimate Gel (Booty Formula/4.2oz)This Sassy Intimate Booty Formula is nice and thick and very slick! On top of it all it is paraben and glyc...

    View full details
    Original price $13.20 - Original price $13.20
    Original price
    $13.20
    $13.20 - $13.20
    Current price $13.20
  • Sold out

    Aneros Wipes | Cleaning Wipes | Antibacterial Toy Cleaner

    Original price $5.06 - Original price $5.06
    Original price
    $5.06
    $5.06 - $5.06
    Current price $5.06

    DESCRIPTION Antibacterial wipes for sex toys of all types and especially anal products.  KEY FEATURE Body-safe and toy-safe.  

    Original price $5.06 - Original price $5.06
    Original price
    $5.06
    $5.06 - $5.06
    Current price $5.06
    Sold out
  • Tantus Perfect Plug Anal Plug Kit Lilac | Butt Plug Kit

    Original price $59.84 - Original price $59.84
    Original price
    $59.84
    $59.84 - $59.84
    Current price $59.84

    DESCRIPTION The Perfect Plug Kit is the perfect way to begin anal exploration. The slender Perfect Plug and its bigger brother the vibrating Perfec...

    View full details
    Original price $59.84 - Original price $59.84
    Original price
    $59.84
    $59.84 - $59.84
    Current price $59.84
  • b-Vibe Snug Plug 1 Weighted Silicone Anal Plug Black | Butt Toy | Anal Health

    Original price $52.25 - Original price $52.25
    Original price
    $52.25
    $52.25 - $52.25
    Current price $52.25

    DESCRIPTION Body safe Silicone weighted butt plug is designed for discreet extender. KEY FEATURE  Smooth grip handle thin flexible neck Waterproof...

    View full details
    Original price $52.25 - Original price $52.25
    Original price
    $52.25
    $52.25 - $52.25
    Current price $52.25
  • Mood - Naughty - Small Black Silicone Butt Plug

    Original price $25.34 - Original price $25.34
    Original price
    $25.34
    $25.34 - $25.34
    Current price $25.34

    DESCRIPTION Doesn't everyone want to be a little naughty? Now, you can regardless of your experience level. This soft silicone anal plug will make ...

    View full details
    Original price $25.34 - Original price $25.34
    Original price
    $25.34
    $25.34 - $25.34
    Current price $25.34
  • Mood Pride Anal Training Set 3-Piece | Anal Kit | Booty Kit

    Original price $38.64 - Original price $38.64
    Original price
    $38.64
    $38.64 - $38.64
    Current price $38.64

    DESCRIPTION This colorful set is perfectly shaped and sized to gently expand the boundaries of one's anal experience. KEY FEATURE Luxurious Velvet...

    View full details
    Original price $38.64 - Original price $38.64
    Original price
    $38.64
    $38.64 - $38.64
    Current price $38.64
  • Mood Naughty 1 Anal Trainer Set Black

    Original price $36.40 - Original price $36.40
    Original price
    $36.40
    $36.40 - $36.40
    Current price $36.40

    DESCRIPTION Help backdoor beginners gently expand the boundaries of their anal experience. KEY FEATURE 3", 4", and 5" Sizes for Training and Varie...

    View full details
    Original price $36.40 - Original price $36.40
    Original price
    $36.40
    $36.40 - $36.40
    Current price $36.40
  •  Intro To Prostate By Zero Tolerance | 4-Piece Prostate Kit
    Zero Tolerance Intro To Prostate | Movie-Lube-Prostate Kit

    Zero Tolerance Intro To Prostate Kit 4-Piece Anal Play Set With DVD

    Original price $43.99 - Original price $43.99
    Original price
    $43.99
    $43.99 - $43.99
    Current price $43.99

    DESCRIPTION Discover the pleasures of prostate play with this kit that moves from beginner to advanced with every stimulating stage in between. Fou...

    View full details
    Original price $43.99 - Original price $43.99
    Original price
    $43.99
    $43.99 - $43.99
    Current price $43.99
  • Nice Butt Plug Quality Silicone Sex Toy
    High Quality Silicone Smooth Butt Plug| Fifty Shades of Grey

    Fifty Shades Forbidden Butt Plug

    Original price $24.20 - Original price $24.20
    Original price
    $24.20
    $24.20 - $24.20
    Current price $24.20

    DESCRIPTION Sensual exploration of your uncharted erogenous zones starts with this petite silicone butt plug. Sized especially for beginners, the s...

    View full details
    Original price $24.20 - Original price $24.20
    Original price
    $24.20
    $24.20 - $24.20
    Current price $24.20

FAQ

What is the best anal toy for beginners?

A small butt plug with a flared base, or a graduated trainer set. Plugs are designed to stay in place without thrusting, which makes them the easiest way to get comfortable. Choose silicone, glass or stainless steel so the toy is easy to clean.

Why does an anal toy need a flared base?

The rectum can draw objects inward. A flared base or handle keeps the toy from slipping all the way in. Never use anything in your bottom that wasn't designed for anal play, and never use a toy without a base.

How much lube do I need for anal play?

More than you think. Apply a generous amount to the toy and the outside of the anus, and reapply whenever things start to feel dry. A thicker water-based anal lube lasts longer and is safe with silicone toys.

Should I use a numbing lube for my first time?

We don't recommend numbing or desensitizing products for beginners. Mild discomfort is your body's way of telling you to slow down, add lube or stop. Numbing that signal makes it easier to go too far, too fast. Relaxation, patience and plenty of lube work better.

Does anal play hurt?

It shouldn't. A feeling of pressure or fullness is normal at first; sharp pain is not. If something hurts, stop. Breathe slowly, relax your muscles, start smaller and try again another day.

How do I prepare and clean up?

A bathroom visit and a quick shower beforehand is usually all you need. Keep wipes and a towel nearby. After play, wash the toy with warm water and mild soap or toy cleaner. Never move a toy from anal to vaginal use without washing it first, or use a fresh condom over it.

Is anal play only for men?

Not at all. People of every gender and body type enjoy anal play. For people with a prostate, gentle internal pressure can feel especially good, and kits like the Intro To Prostate Kit are designed with that in mind.

Can I use an anal toy with a partner?

Yes, and a plug worn during sex is a popular first step together. App-controlled plugs like the Lovense Hush 2 let a partner control the vibration. Talk first, agree on a stop word, and let the person receiving set the pace. Find more ideas in First Toy for Couples.